Coffee Percolator vs Moka pot: The final verdict

Nolan Killey

September 29, 2022

Coffee Percolator vs Moka pot: The final verdict

Key takeaways

Coffee percolator vs Moka pot

  • Coffee percolators are less expensive than Moka pots.
  • Moka pots produce a higher quality cup of coffee than percolators.
  • Percolators take longer to brew a pot of coffee than Moka pots.
  • Moka pots are more portable than percolators.

When it comes to coffee, there are two camps: those who prefer the simplicity of the coffee percolator, and those who go for the richer flavor of the moka pot. But which is better?

Introduction

The coffee percolator and moka pot are two popular coffee-making methods. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages. In this article, we will pit the two methods against each other to see which one comes out on top.

The coffee percolator

percolator coffee photo
Photo by matsuyuki

The coffee percolator is a quick and easy way to make coffee. It’s an affordable option for those on a budget, and it’s a good choice for those who want a simple cup of coffee. However, the coffee percolator is not the best choice for those who want a rich and intense flavor.

The coffee percolator works by boiling water and forcing it up through a tube and over the grounds. This process is repeated multiple times, which results in a strong cup of coffee. However, because the water is in contact with the grounds for a longer period of time, the coffee can sometimes taste bitter.

If you’re looking for a quick cup of coffee, then the coffee percolator is a good option. However, if you’re after a more intense flavor, then you might want to try the moka pot.

Advantages

As mentioned before, the coffee percolator is a quick and easy way to make coffee. It’s also more affordable than the moka pot, and more portable.

The percolator is easier to use than the moka pot because you don’t have to worry about grinding the beans or adding the correct amount of water. You simply add the beans and water, and let the percolator do its job.

Another advantage of the percolator is that it can make large batches of coffee at once, which is great if you’re having friends over.

One thing to keep in mind, however, is that the percolator doesn’t provide as much control over the brewing process as the moka pot does. So if you’re looking for a cup of coffee that’s exactly to your liking, the moka pot may be a better option.

Disadvantages

The coffee percolator has several disadvantages when compared to the moka pot. Firstly, the coffee percolator is not as portable as the moka pot. This means that it is not as convenient to take with you on the go. Secondly, the coffee percolator is not as easy to use as the moka pot. This means that it can be more time-consuming and difficult to make a cup of coffee with a percolator. Finally, the coffee percolator does not produce as strong of a flavor as the moka pot. This is because the moka pot extracts more of the coffee’s oils and flavors, resulting in a richer cup of coffee.

The moka pot

moka pot photo

The moka pot is the better option for those who are looking for a more intense flavor. The moka pot is more expensive than the coffee percolator, but it is worth the extra money. The moka pot is more difficult to use than the coffee percolator, but the results are worth the effort. The moka pot is less portable than the coffee percolator, but it can be used to make larger batches of coffee. The final verdict: the moka pot is the better option for those who are looking for a more intense flavor and are willing to spend more money.

Advantages

The coffee percolator is a quick and easy way to make coffee. All you need to do is add water and grounds, and the percolator does the rest. The percolator is also very affordable. You can find them for less than $20 in most stores.

The moka pot produces a richer and more intense flavor. This is because the moka pot uses pressure to force hot water through the grounds, extracting more of the coffee’s flavor. The moka pot is more portable than the percolator. They’re small and lightweight, making them easy to take with you on the go.

The moka pot brews coffee faster than the percolator. This is because the percolator takes longer to heat up the water, and then it has to brew for longer to extract all of the flavor from the grounds.

Disadvantages

While the coffee percolator is a quick and easy way to make coffee, it doesn’t produce the same rich flavor as the moka pot. This is because the water in a percolator is constantly recirculated, which can result in a slightly bitter taste.

The coffee percolator is also less portable than the moka pot, making it less convenient for those on the go. This is because the percolator needs to be plugged into an outlet, whereas the moka pot can be used on any type of stove.

Finally, the coffee percolator is more expensive than the moka pot, making it less budget-friendly for those who are watching their pennies. This is because the percolator requires a special heating element, which adds to the overall cost.

Other factors to consider

Here are more factors to consider

Serving size

When it comes to serving size, the coffee percolator has a clear advantage over the moka pot. The coffee percolator is able to brew large quantities of coffee at once, making it perfect for large gatherings. On the other hand, the moka pot is better suited for smaller servings, as it can be difficult to get the ratio of coffee to water right when making a large batch.

Therefore, if you’re looking for a coffee maker that can serve a large group of people, the percolator is the way to go. However, if you’re only making coffee for yourself or a small group of people, the moka pot is a better option.

Portability

When it comes to portability, the coffee percolator has the upper hand. The coffee percolator is the more convenient option when you’re on the go. The moka pot is less portable than the coffee percolator, but it’s still manageable.

If you’re looking for a coffee maker that you can take with you on the go, the coffee percolator is the way to go. The moka pot is a bit more cumbersome, but it’s still doable. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide which coffee maker is right for you.

Coffee Taste

When it comes to coffee taste, the moka pot is the clear winner. The coffee percolator produces a more watered-down cup of coffee. This is because the percolator evenly distributes the water over the grounds, resulting in a brew that’s less concentrated.

On the other hand, the moka pot lets you control the strength of your coffee. By adjusting the amount of water you use, you can make a weaker or stronger cup of coffee. This flexibility means that you can tailor your coffee to your personal taste.

In addition, the moka pot produces a richer, fuller-bodied cup of coffee. This is because the boiling water only comes into contact with the grounds for a short period of time. This results in a coffee that’s less bitter and has more complex flavors.

Brew time and control

When it comes to brew time, the coffee percolator is much quicker than the moka pot. This is because the percolator uses boiling water to force the coffee up through the filter. The moka pot, on the other hand, uses steam pressure to slowly extract the flavor from the coffee grounds.

The coffee percolator is also much easier to control, giving you more consistent results. This is because you can control the amount of water that flows through the grounds, as well as the temperature. With a moka pot, it’s very easy to over or under-extract the coffee, resulting in a less than perfect cup.

However, the moka pot produces a richer and more intense flavor. This is because all of the water comes into contact with the coffee grounds, extracting more of the flavor compounds. The percolator, on the other hand, only extract a small amount of flavor from the grounds.

Costs

When it comes to costs, the coffee percolator is the cheaper option. You can find a good quality percolator for around $30. The moka pot, on the other hand, will set you back at least $50.

That said, the moka pot is worth the extra cost for the improved flavor. The rich, full-bodied taste of moka pot coffee is simply unmatched by the percolator. If you’re serious about your coffee, then the moka pot is the way to go.

Of course, if you’re on a budget, the coffee percolator is still a perfectly viable option. It may not produce the best possible flavor, but it’s a whole lot cheaper than the moka pot.

At the end of the day, it’s up to you to decide which coffee-making method is right for you. If cost is your main concern, then the percolator is the way to go. But if you’re after the best possible flavor, then the moka pot is worth the extra cost.

The final verdict

After taking everything into consideration, it is clear that the coffee percolator and the moka pot both have their pros and cons. The coffee percolator is the better choice for those who are looking for a quick and easy cup of coffee. On the other hand, the moka pot is the better option for those who are after a more intense flavor.

Of course, there are other factors to consider, such as serving size, portability, coffee taste, brew time and control, and costs. But at the end of the day, it’s up to you to decide which coffee-making method is right for you.

So, which is better – the coffee percolator or the moka pot? Well, it depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a quick and easy cup of coffee, go with the percolator. If you’re after a more intense flavor, go with the moka pot. And if you’re considering other factors like price and convenience, there are pros and cons to both methods. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide which coffee-making method is right for you.

About Nolan Killey

Nolan is a keen traveller who loves to explore the world and taste new cuisines. She’s also a coffee lover, and enjoys sampling different blends from all over the globe. Her blog chronicles her travels and culinary experiences, as well as providing helpful tips for travelers and foodies. Anna likes to inject a healthy dose of humour into her writing, making her blog an enjoyable read for everyone.

Leave a Comment